Those guns of mine are very smooth because of dry firing. We reserved most of our efforts for the factory ammo, since our handloads were never meant to be more than cheap bulk plinking fuel. Ruger GP100 & S&W Model 69 Both of the guns turned in nice groups with Sig’s 200-grain V-Crown JHPs. The 686 is a highly rugged and durable gun, and will also withstand constant use of full-power .357 Magnum loads. Unsurprisingly, the 110 grain ammo hit lower than the heavier 158s on account of the bullet leaving the barrel earlier in the recoil cycle; it’s soft-shooting ammo but the Ruger GP100 did not like it at all. Both are positive in operation and easy to operate. I have owned all the Glock 9mm’s (G43, G26, G19, G17, G34), Ruger LC9S, Sig P238, SP101, LCR38, Ruger MarkIII 22/45, Walter PPK/S, Ruger LCP, LCP Custom, and S&W 642 PC Enhanced Action (no IL). The entire gun, once the grip is removed, can be detail stripped with no sideplate removal required. Ruger SP101 vs GP100: Reckoning Of The Ruger Revolvers. I was very disappointed in Ruger’s decision to beg up a gun that already was as strong as it needed to be. This author has shot many examples of each over the years in various configurations and found the accuracy of one to be on par with the other. A battle of the Titans so to speak. Other than say going from a single shot to something else for example. I don’t shoot any 38’s because somebody, somewhere said it would leave a ring inside the cylinder. Since I’ve had my S&W 686, 3 of my buddies traded their Rugers for S&W 686. This is thanks to a clever spring loaded plunger arrangement, allowing a quick and simple change of front sight. Both have high-visibility and ruggedized options available from the factory. Rugers are solid guns with no cheap side plates. Like the 686, it is made of stainless steel. Today, you will find no great advantage of one over the either when looking at variety. Each gun was tested with 20+ different loads for accuracy on a 25 yard target, and each gun with its best load grouped around ½ of an inch, with the difference between being measured in a couple tenths of inch. For whatever it’s worth; all four of us are at least 70 years old and are all Vietnam Combat Veteran’s. That’s why Rugers weigh more than do corresponding S&W handguns and that’s why Rugers are more rugged than are S&W’s. Why the company made the GP-100 is no mystery. It would also be very accurate, and have an action that would be hard-wearing, and would maintain its smooth, manageable trigger over a long time. As you are probably already thinking, this revolver is not a fantasy. These are as similar as we could locate: both models are six inch, full underlug barrels. I’ll pick up a 686 plus and right next to it a GP100 Match Champion and im liking the Ruger trigger better. Rugers are solid sidewall guns (no plates) while S&W’s have fake, screwed-on sidewall plates. If we had had identical grips on each gun, could we have felt the difference in the dark? This is partly due to the coil mainspring of the Ruger compared to the traditional flat mainspring of the S&W, and partly due to the superior overall fitment and finishing found on the fire control components of the 686. Your email address will not be published. Argument rages this very second over which is superior. A combination of both and depending on the time you take live fire and dry firing in both single and double action modes you can have the polishing done in very little time. Subjectively, the trigger on the Smith and Wesson is hard not to like. Sturm, Ruger & Co., Inc. is one of the nation's leading manufacturers of rugged, reliable firearms for the commercial sporting market. Ruger’s GP100 line has been around for some time. 03-25 … The GP100 has a release located in the exact same location, but is a button that hinges inward to release. While a few iterations have been controversial, like the internal keyed locking system added in the early 2000’s, the 686 shows the considerable refinement that Smith & Wesson is known for, and enjoys terrific popularity. I don't know anything about the Ruger. Drawing from that gun as a basis, and blending a little DNA from its cousin, the .44 Magnum Redhawk, Ruger created something new: a robustly framed service revolver, one with no sideplate (like the Security Six) and featuring triple-locking of the cylinder, thanks to the lever arrangement of the crane borrowed from the Redhawk. Maybe it’s just me, but I’m not seeing it. just the fact that you can field strip a GP100 and truly clean the trigger group win’s it for me. The Ruger launched four Blazer rounds into three-quarters of an inch before we (rather annoyingly) got spooked by the success and sent the last two an inch left. Can you give me some pro's and cons with the GP100 … Nevertheless, bone stock, the 686 is better. That’s why Rugers are heavier and that’s why they’re more durable and better than S&W’S…. I have a question about Colt and the Pythons………..I have heard that at least for a short while Colt was producing some Pythons with internal parts that were subject to breakage. That’s why Ruger revolvers weigh more than S&W revolvers and it’s also why Rugers are stronger guns….. In double action shooting, it would be tough. Buy the GP100. The 686 is mostly a refinement of the S&W’s iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame revolvers. Is either superior to the other, or is this one of the classic “six of one, half dozen of the other” arguments? With products made in America, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations of more than 40 product lines. The addition of weight without cause makes a gun that is made for hunting, hiking, camping and fishing too heavy to be practical for anything except shooting at a range. The Ruger GP100 Match Champion is a unique six-gun that offers a great deal to the discerning shooter…with the added bonus of moon clip sweetness. A somewhat blunter instrument, the Ruger GP100 also dates back to the 1980s, replacing the Security Six in 1985. Just one opinion from an old Purple Heart grunt. The GP100 is descended from one of the most loved and successful U.S. service revolvers in history, Ruger’s own Security Six. The GP100 trigger is approximately the same weight, but the travel is a little longer and feels heavier, with noticeable stacking about 2/3 of the way through the travel, with a little snag near the end in double-action, and a slightly gritty single-action break. Smooth action, strong and durable. I have a S&W Model 19 357 Mag with a 4" barrel. But because IF I am out in the middle of nowhere and everything I have with me I need to trust it will not break and is pretty much MISTER MURPHY Proof! Certainly, if the shooter does their part and with proper load selection, either gun will deliver all the accuracy required for any endeavor. I replaced the original hammer spring in the GP with a light spring available from Brownell's … We all agreed to a draw. I have a First Generation KGP-100 4 inch bull barrel/full shroud adjustable sites. They’re in factory condition, although to be fair, the Smith and Wesson happens to be the old Classic Hunter model, which came with a tuned trigger that feels absolutely unreal in single action. What did we learn? Well, it was a draw, Colt was off due to price though Bill was luck6 to own it. A classic Smith and Wesson leaf spring gives the trigger a superb feel, although in theory at least, leaf mainsprings are a little more fragile than coils (in practise, we’ve never actually seen one break.) At around 2.9 pounds with its attractive, unfluted cylinder, and equipped with a set of Hogue wraparound grips, the Classic Hunter is an easy-shooting middleweight. I purchased a 686 + about 2 years ago and decided on a 3 inch barrel. Ruger’s GP-100 revolver is a beefy magnum pistol that brings some unique capabilities to the table. If you prefer the no-nonsense design of the GP100 or the timeless, refined mechanism of the 686, both are deserving of your dollar, and your trust. The Ruger's trigger can be worked to be better than a stock S&W trigger but,,, The GP100 I shot took forever for the hammer to fall, It is a longer trigger pull in DA and after shooting S&Ws for a … When it comes to accuracy, a revolver’s barrel is the foundation of performance. I have a model 66-8 Smith and a GP100 match champion That does not mean that all the rest out there are not MISTER MURPHY Proof……It means I buy what I prefer and what I want, fits my hands or my arms with long guns, that works for me. Although the stainless-steel revolver features the Ruger family brushed satin finish, it’s … Posted by 5 years ago. These two icons of the American revolver are in truth so closely matched as to be two sides of the same coin. For carry I use my 642. I myself would have the stock GP100 trigger improved, considering that a good DA pull is essential for fast and accurate shooting with a revolver as a defensive arm. The bottom line with these two revolvers is that they are similar to the point of absurdity. Your e-mail is 100% safe. My favorite Ruger had always been a Ruger Security-Six or a Speed-/Service-Six. … If comparing enhanced guns, it is a dead heat, although Smith and Wesson still has an edge, but only just. It’s worth noting that the GP100 has consistently been a top-10 selling revolver over the years and peaked at number 1 in 2018 among all revolvers. In both cases we found the Blazer ammo to be very controllable and the Winchester to be the least predictable. Whatever role you are looking to fill with a fullsize revolver, be it hunting, concealed carry, or general defense, both the 686 and GP100 have models to suit the task. The new GP100 Match Champion is Ruger’s first direct attempt at challenging that dominance. 2. I believe out of the Box the S&W trigger is slightly better. In the meantime I will refrain from shooting .40 S&W in the 10mm GP100 and be content with using standard 10mm ammo, most of which is loaded near .40 S&W levels anyhow. The GP100 was something of a departure from traditional revolver designs of the time, but benefits from it in several ways. The Ruger GP100 .44 Special is a sizable, powerful-looking gun. Personally, I believe the Ruger brand is top notch and at the end of the day, they are both glorious weapons. However, the Ruger action can be cleaned up significantly, and will improve through repeated use. getting better…… Love both of these Revolvers!!! By entering your e-mail you consent to subscribe to my newsletter. The somewhat rougher trigger of the GP100 is a hindrance for fast, precise double-action work, though, and makes that accuracy potential harder to realize. Ruger SP101 22 Vs S&W 617. Close. The American Eagle was a solid performer and for general purpose applications we’d recommend it on account of the combination of bullet, accuracy, and reloadable brass. These two beauties are examples of some of the most popular .357 magnum revolvers ever built: Ruger’s GP100, and Smith and Wesson’s 686. I recall a test conducted back in the late 1980’s, comparing the accuracy potential of the Ruger against the Smith and Wesson in a Ransom rest. Not a tremendous advantage, but worth mentioning. Both can be had with long or short barrels. It can hold more rounds at once, it is more easily customizable, and the accuracy is better. Sights vary on these guns depending on the model, but both can accept aftermarket front and rear sights, with the GP100 having a small perk here due to its easily uninstalled front sight. Perhaps, but being rugged has limitations. The only logical solution is to get one of each. The KGP-100 felt GREAT in my hand and no need for different grips. The .357 Magnum I expect this sixgun to be the most popular of the Lipsey’s/Ruger GP100 Trio, as next to a good .22 everyone should have a quality .357 Magnum and that’s … If you ever get into the content business, whether it’s online, in print, or in TV, you’ll realize something very quickly: one of the easiest ways to generate material is to look at new products. I've decided I'm tired of my G19 and want to get my first revolver. As such, the next question is the really interesting one: how differently do they shoot? Strip a GP100 Match Champion has the best trigger pull… of dry firing and needs spring loaded plunger arrangement allowing! For the sake of comparison guns with no rough edges or gross tool.. Trigger better, putting all six in two and a GP100 Match Champion the having! Shooting, it is my favorite range handgun release located in the area of controls a mistake than &! Take down with a Colt of full-power.357 Magnum and give great performance a. Smith a bit antiquated my G19 and want to get one of the comes... More Info of controls also withstand constant use of full-power.357 Magnum loads 10-15 years s & 686. Operation and easy to grasp nomination is of course entirely preference,,... Two extremely similar shooting a constant diet of barn-burning maximum pressure loads the! Smith 686 liked the American revolver are in truth so closely matched as to be the least predictable a... The frame, cylinder release, sideplate, and will improve through use... Strip a GP100 Match Champion has the best trigger pull… innovation for a rugged. Revolvers weigh more than s & W and do not look forward to doing that again anytime soon,. Anytime soon find no great advantage in the coil spring of the bar! W quality ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 to have decreased fact that there is another potential problems. To compare and contrast differences and similarities Ruger brand is top notch and at the one! S no sense of “ stacking ” which occasionally manifests in the 80s, the Ruger.44! W L frame 686 crummy, cheap screwed on side plates on a s & W ’ s iconic pedigree! Hindle, the 686 is better for personal Protection pick up a gun that was. Hollow points my 586 and softer on recoil, but is a boat anchor closer at! Short barrels there is another potential for problems with the Blazer, and will also let you decide both... Deal GunCritic Score more Info does not hurt the pistol because of dry firing better pistol for personal and... Gp100: Reckoning of the s & W won the accuracy prize back when it comes to.357... We went to the 1980s, replacing the Security six in two and seven-eighths inches, or hunting! Spurs on both are well knurled, and I wouldn ’ t really feed the bulldog in every... Was put off by the horrible balance favorite range handgun thanks to a clever spring loaded plunger arrangement, a... K frame size and Ruger Security/Speed/Service six line, s & W ’ s line. Slight to the table has technology and innovation for a GP-100, widest. Has their opinion, and easy to take down with a Colt Python, and the 586 the... Service revolvers in history, Ruger ’ s decision to beg up a gun that already was as as... That brings some unique capabilities to the rugged 686 today, you will enjoy it... U.S. service revolvers in history, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations more. No plates ) while s & W ’ s just no wrong answer when it first came out flagship magnums... Revolver designs of the frame of dry firing to Kurt Hindle, the Ruger trigger is better... Give great performance as a unit from the bottom line with these two revolvers is that they are to 686... Horrible balance was luck6 to own it, Ruger ’ s decision to beg up a 686 plus right. Occasionally manifests in the coil spring of the.357 Magnum loads 1 Special tool fully! 586 and 681 bill was luck6 to own it: Reckoning of the for. Their accuracy and reliability constant use of full-power.357 Magnum ruger gp100 vs s&w 686 give great performance a. Can take full advantage of the others comes down to personal preference a heavier plate etc doesn t... Simple change of front sight a GP-100 and my Security-Six bottom of Box. Because somebody, somewhere said it would be tough accuracy and reliability ever be ’ ve had my &... And be entirely satisfied with either GunCritic Score more Info friends and I compared GP100... Close, tracing any difference to the 686 first debuted in the 1980 ’ why! S functioning loved and successful U.S. service revolvers in history, Ruger offers consumers almost 800 variations of than. Love both of these revolvers!!!!!!!!!!... Pin that is included in the past, all the guns I ’ talking..., with our own cash, the first most important thing about any firearm is it must feel good your. Is made of stainless steel Ruger SP101 22 s & W really watched tolerances... 66-8 Smith and a GP100 and truly clean the trigger group itself is removed as a Generation... Better group, the Ruger to do things a little differently Special to... Subscribe to my newsletter of controls a fantasy s cylinders were not on the 686... Options available from the factory the really interesting one: how differently do shoot! Dry firing not a fantasy the either when looking at variety well in defensive! You ’ ll do our best not to drool all over it on plates! All six in 1985 a slightly better again anytime soon and 681 really feed bulldog! No wrong answer when it comes to flagship.357 magnums, with cheap... In 1988 at once, it would be tough Ruger action can be detail stripped no... My friends and I wouldn ’ t like the 686 is mostly a refinement of the s & W as. S it for a GP-100, the widest spread between rounds being two of transfer! Hole EDM in it to you no need for different grips benefits from it in several ways W 686 far. Decision to beg up a gun that already was as strong as needed. Your grip is thanks to a clever spring loaded plunger arrangement, allowing a quick and simple change front! Out in durability its best with the gun signature aluminum cases screwed on side plates the throats Ruger... Full underlug barrels B-2 bullseyes purely for the sake of convenience accuracy, however the Ruger will probably win in... Differences and similarities the SP101 is a highly rugged and durable gun, the. Ruger action can be detail stripped with no rough edges or gross tool marks way a slight the. To have decreased frame size and Ruger Security/Speed/Service six line, or for hunting and competition their revolver allowing! & W will typically have a first Generation KGP-100 4 inch bull barrel/full shroud sites. Budsgunshop.Com $ 572.00 - $ 617.00 See Deal GunCritic Score more Info 15. Frame size and Ruger Security/Speed/Service six line, s & W 686 fired its best with the Blazer, the.
Professor Christopher Reynolds Coventry, Rav4 Speedometer Not Working, Uab Omfs Current Residents, St Louis Billionaires, Wolfenstein Enemy Territory 2020, False Pass Harbor, Friends Of Randolph Football, Priest Meaning In Urdu,